Three books lined up in front of a window.
There was a wealth of books to read through at Commerce Chooses. | Photo credit: Patrick C. Harrison III

At Commerce Chooses, Young Readers Helped Pick the Year’s Best Picture Books

Animated readings and spirited discussions brought campus and community together to celebrate the artistry, meaning and joy of picture books.

Children sat on the floor of Talbot Hall, absorbed in picture books pulled from displays on tables and windowsills. Later, they settled on the floor again for the read-alouds. This time, performers switched voices and made sound effects as the stories called for them. Adults listened quietly, many of them smiling; funny moments drew bursts of laughter from the crowd.

The Nov. 14 event, Commerce Chooses: Best Picture Book, brought children, families, students and faculty to East Texas A&M University for an afternoon of reading, performances and friendly literary debate. Readers spent two and a half hours exploring the books before voting to narrow the field to 10 finalists. After discussing the finalists, they picked winners in three new categories.

A vote for readers of all ages

Dr. Rebecca Rowe, an assistant professor of children's literature, got the idea for Commerce Chooses during her master's program at Kansas State University. At its annual Mock Caldecott event, students, faculty and community members gathered to consider which picture book might win the national award. The youngest readers had plenty to say.

“It was the first time I saw children knowing better than scholars as they told us what we missed about these books and reminded us that a good picture book shouldn't be boring,” Rowe said.

When Rowe joined East Texas A&M, she asked Dr. Kelin Loe to help start a similar event in Commerce. Loe had fallen in love with picture books while working in a bookstore and earning her Master of Fine Arts in poetry. She saw the event as a chance to share art through words, illustrations, voices and music while building connections among readers.

The first Commerce Chooses in 2023 followed the Mock Caldecott format. Local readers even picked the same book as the national committee, Vashti Harrison's “Big.” By 2025, the discussion had turned to a question Loe recalled hearing during deliberations: “Distinguished to WHOM exactly?” Loe continued, “What feels distinguished to children is different than what feels distinguished to the Caldecott Committee—and that too is different to English professors and grad students and parents and undergrads and big sisters and brothers and childcare workers.”

Some books stood out for their artistry, others for the way they conveyed a difficult idea, and still others for how much fun they were to read aloud again and again. Those conversations led organizers to create three awards this year. Children and adults had a say in all three.

Faculty, students and staff took part in animated readings for the audience. | Photo credit: Patrick C. Harrison III

“What a lot of people don't realize about picture books is that they're intentionally designed for a dual audience: for a child and adult reading together,” Rowe said.

Students help put on the show

Graduate students have helped find and select books since the event's early years. This year, students in Karen Walker's undergraduate education class and Dr. Darla Meek's music education class helped evaluate titles ahead of the event. Honors College students volunteered, and East Texas A&M's Velma K. Waters Library purchased books for the event.

The read-alouds also expanded after a pilot with theater students in 2025. This year, theater students performed alongside faculty, librarians and staff. Between live performances, the audience heard recordings by Meek's music education students, who used instruments to add music and sound effects to the stories.

“Every bedtime book is an opportunity—for both reader and listener, caretakers and kids—for artistic encounter, for ritual, for exposure to new ideas, for questions, and for the struggle to find the best answers we have,” Loe said.

The 2026 winners

  • Best Made — “Hometown” by Shaun Tan. The award recognizes the book's artistry, including how the writing and illustrations work together.
  • Best Read — “Dragon Dog” by Suzanne and Max Lang. The award recognizes a book readers can enjoy performing aloud, even after repeated readings.
  • Best Message — “Barbed Wire Between Us” by Mia Wenjen and Violeta Encarnación. The award recognizes how effectively a book conveys an important idea.

East Texas A&M's Department of Literature and Languages hosted Commerce Chooses. The department offers a variety of degree plans from undergraduate to Ph.D. that help prepare students for written and linguistic expertise in English or Spanish.